Meet Our Judges For 2026

Chair of Judges

Robert Paul

Robert’s early years as a winemaker were somewhat peripatetic, with spells at Amberton in Mudgee, Lindemans at Karadoc and Corowa and the newly established Chapel Hill in McLaren Vale. From there he went downhill to Coriole where he stayed for a few years until returning to Mudgee to work for Montrose Wines.

After ten happy years at Montrose, they moved to Melbourne where Robert took up a consultancy role, advising wine businesses around Australia and internationally. In that role, he has worked in France, Argentina, Chile, China, Bulgaria, New Zealand and Turkey as well as most wine regions in Australia.
​
In addition, Robert has been involved in many wine shows as Judge and Chief Judge, including Adelaide, Melbourne, Rutherglen, Cowra and Mudgee and of course the International Cool Climate Wine Show. From 2016 to 2022, Robert took on the role as Director of the Victorian Wine Show.

Panel Chair

Lisa Cardelli

Lisa Cardelli is an Italian-born wine professional who has called Australia home for the past 15 years. After more than a decade in fine dining- including head sommelier at Neil Perry’s Rosetta – her experience expanded in Tuscany, where she worked at a Michelin-starred restaurant.

With a WSET Level 4 Diploma and sommelier certification, Lisa teaches WSET courses across Melbourne. In recent years, she has transitioned into wine journalism, becoming an award-winning and prolific bilingual writer, with work published in WinePilot, Halliday Wine Companion, Qantas Travel Insider, and Decanter.

Since 2024, Lisa has judged both Australia’s and China’s Wine List of the Year Awards and has participated in local and national wine shows since 2015. She has explored Italy’s most prominent wine regions and was selected for the Family of Twelve Tutorial in New Zealand in 2019. Maintaining strong ties with New Zealand, she reviewed wines from both islands and in 2025 was invited to judge the Central Otago Spring Release tasting. Lisa is also a Len Evans Tutorial alumnus (2024), widely regarded as one of the world’s most respected wine education programs.

Panel Chair

Toby Stephens

After an inspiring start in fine wine retail in Perth, Toby studied Oenology at the University of Adelaide and graduated as dux in 2002.
​
The flying winemaker lifestyle then took hold, with vintages spanning Margaret River, Barossa Valley, Marlborough, Langhorne Creek, the Clare Valley and Corsica.
​
​Toby was a ‘Vin de Champagne’ winner and explored the Champagne region extensively on the back of this award. He completed the AWRI Advanced Wine Assessment course in 2004 and has been a judge for Winestate magazine and the International Cool Climate Wine Show over several years.
​
​Toby’s career pivoted to wine wholesale in 2006 and he became a director and state sales manager for Bacchus Wine Merchant until late 2023. He was instrumental in selecting quality imported wines from cool-climate regions including Piedmont, Central Otago, Champagne, Chablis, Alsace & Mosel.

In 2024, Toby became Head of Sales for Vin Merchants – a start-up winemaking and wine distribution venture. He contributes across the breadth of winemaking, blending and brand development and also tastes extensively, selecting new wineries for the growing portfolio.

Keep an eye out for his first solo release wine – 2025 Helix Grenache, hand-picked from a single vineyard in Heathcote.

Show Judge

Matt Lugg

Matt Lugg is a winemaker and viticulturalist at Portsea Estate, where he has worked since 2021. As well as this role, Matt founded Lugg Wines in 2020, a sparkling-focused label dedicated to crafting premium sparkling wines from the Mornington Peninsula, reflecting both site and precision in winemaking.

Matt brings a broad depth of experience shaped by work across several renowned regions. In Australia, he has made wine on the Mornington Peninsula, Geelong, and in the Hunter Valley, while internationally he has worked in both the Southern Rhône Valley—returning for two vintages—and Burgundy. These experiences have informed his approach to both viticulture and winemaking, with an emphasis on balance, energy, and regional expression.

With a decade of involvement in wine shows, Matt values the opportunity judging provides to engage and learn with peers and continually refine his palate. He particularly appreciates the discipline and insight gained from blind tasting, as well as the chance to assess a wide spectrum of wines at a high level.

In addition to his professional experience, Matt has undertaken extensive international wine travel, further broadening his perspective and deepening his understanding of global wine styles, regions, and traditions.

Show Judge

Courtney Keegan

Courtney has spent the past decade working across hospitality and liquor retail, building a genuine love for wine and the stories behind it. A big part of that journey has been her time with Dan Murphy’s, where she had the chance to connect with a huge range of customers — from casual drinkers to serious collectors — and help them find something they’re genuinely excited about. Courtney also hosted many masterclasses, was a part of judging for various Dan Murphy’s campaigns (eg. Best in Glass Awards) and conducted many of instore wine training sessions for Dan Murphy’s team members. She was heavily involved in Dan’s Women in Drinks, an advocacy group dedicated to supporting, celebrating, and elevating women across the drinks industry.

Last year Courtney was selected to take part in the Sommeliers Australia Education Scholarship. This rare opportunity gave her the chance to blind sample countless benchmark examples of wines from Australia and Internationally and helped to put some of the most revered wines into perspective and a chance to learn from the best. Since then, Courtney became a Sommeliers Australia Committee member and hosted a number of masterclasses to contribute to the wine community. She is also a Rootlings Victorian State Champion where she helps to promote and connect young wine industry professionals with the wider community and also to run activations for these young professionals so they can learn, connect and collaborate. She has also recently been accepted as a committee member for the Victorian Chapter of Wine Communicators Australia where Courtney hopes to be able to contribute further to the Australian Wine Industry.

Show Judge

Cyndal Petty

Cyndal Petty is a Western Australian wine and restaurant writer, critic and presenter. She is a regular contributor to Halliday, Broadsheet and Sitchu, and a critic for Winepilot, where her work brings a contemporary, culturally driven lens to Australian wine. Alongside writing, Cyndal works across television and live events as a presenter and host, leading panels and tastings both nationally and internationally.

A chef-turned-sommelier, in a previous role as Group Sommelier, Cyndal oversaw seven wine lists, holding one of Western Australia’s most significant wine-hospitality positions. During this time, she built and guided the wine team, contributing to multiple accolades, including Gourmet Traveller Wine Bar of the Year for a venue opened under her tenure.

Cyndal judges a minimum of three wine shows annually, where she is known for precision, clarity and a lens shaped by both technical training and stylistic awareness. Having worked extensively across wine lists in both Australian and international contexts, her palate carries a global perspective, grounded in structure, intent and relevance. Her judging extends beyond the bench to industry panels, moderated tastings and international engagements with producers, buyers and audiences.

Her approach is defined by clear, confident assessment and an ability to situate wines within both tradition and modern drinking culture.

Show Judge (New Zealand)

Sammy WIlkinson

With over 17 years in the global wine industry, Sammy Wilkinson is a New Zealand-based wine reviewer and judge. Originally from the UK and now based in Nelson, she is known as The Wine Writer, an independent platform focused on clear, commercially relevant reviews that help both trade and consumers quickly understand what is worth drinking, and she also contributes as WinePilot’s only New Zealand-based reviewer.

By day, she works as a brand manager across a portfolio of New Zealand wine brands at Booster Wine Group. She is a Stage 2 Master of Wine student, WSET Diploma holder, and certified WSET educator. Her background includes hands-on harvest experience in Nelson, Marlborough, and Sonoma, giving her a grounded understanding of how winery decisions translate into what’s in the glass.

She has judged for three years at the National Wine Awards of Aotearoa and at regional wine competitions. Her judging style is direct and pragmatic, focused on wines that are well made, true to style, and deliver within their category. Through The Wine Writer and her global experience across production, sales, and marketing, she has built a reputation for reviews that are clear, consistent, and easy to trust.

Show Judge

Cameron Moore

With over twenty-five years of experience in all areas of wine, Cam is a highly motivated and passionate wine professional. This experience includes working at a range of wineries where he undertaking all facets of wine making. However, his interest has always been the food and wine retail management and wholesaling, where he has designed restaurant wine lists to meet clientele needs. With his travels, reviewing and selecting wines for wine lists more many years, Cam has continually developed a strong product knowledge of both Australian and International wines.

Cam has a proven track record of implementing strategies to enhance the wine culture and customer experience, which has led to profitable outcomes. With a well-developed network of long-term customer loyalty and industry relationships, together with the completed WSET Diploma Level 4 and accredited judging at the Royal Melbourne Wine Awards, Cameron’s career in the wine industry is showing great momentum. He is looking forward to judging with the International Cool Climate Wine Show for the first time, in 2026.

Show Judge

Chris Strickland

Chris has been head winemaker at Foxeys Hangout on the Mornington Peninsula since 2020, taking over from owner Tony Lee. A Mornington local with a passion for organic and biodynamic vineyard/winery practices that has become the is driving force of the development of Foxeys vineyard and winemaking programs.

Chris has judging experience at the Mornington Peninsula Wine Show and the Australian Pinot Noir challenge. Chris was also a finalist in the 2023 Young Guns of Wine winemaker of the year awards.

Excellence in Environmental Sustainability Award 2026 Judging Panel

Lead Sustainability Judge

Hayley Purbrick

Hayley Purbrick is a proud fifth generation family member of one of the oldest wine-making families and carbon neutral wineries in Australia, celebrating 100 years of ownership this year. Hayley led the winery to achieve net-zero status, making it one of the first wineries globally to reach this milestone.

Outside of the winery Hayley lives in Echuca and is an advocate for a nature positive future, growing strong agricultural industries and thriving rural communities. In 2015 she founded social enterprise Big Sky Ideas to champion entrepreneurial spirit in rural Australia and is due to release her first book ‘Green Future’ in July 2025.

In 2017 she was a Finalist of both the Regional Australia Institute Light Bulb Moments Competition and NSW/ACT Agrifutures Rural Woman of the Year. In 2019 she graduated from the Wine Australia Future Leaders Program.

Hayley is a current judge of the National Banksia Sustainability Awards and in 2022 was recognised for her contribution to sustainability work by the Melbourne Food & Wine Festival as Sustainability Legend, she holds qualifications in Sustainability and Social Impact, Marketing, Service Design, Commerce and Agriculture.

Sustainability Judge

Peter Dobney

Peter is a retired Mechanical Engineer who worked for over 30 years on energy supply and energy management projects.

He worked for Amcor and later Orora for over 20 years until he retired.

Peter was Amcor’s Group General Manager for Energy for energy supply, energy efficiency, sustainability and CO2 emission reductions.

In 2000 when Peter commenced work at Amcor they spent over $200M on electricity and gas. He reduced this by 25% by implementing energy efficiency in many of their manufacturing plants and won the Australian Energy Efficiency Council’s award for Sustainability in Manufacturing in 2014 and in 2016 the New Zealand Energy Efficiency Award.

Peter was the founding President of the Energy User Association of Australia (EUAA) and was EUAA’s committee member for Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO). He was a member of the EUAA Board for 20 years.

As well as managing energy use and efficiency of Amcor’s existing manufacturing plants Peter was involved in the construction of Amcor’s Glass Plant at Gawler in South Australia; the largest manufacturing facility of wine bottles in Australia.

Peter often spent time meeting with some of Amcor’s (later Orora’s), wine customer’s providing them with some ideas to reduce the energy usage at their wine plants.

One of the last projects that Peter worked on at Orora’s Botany Paper Mill in NSW was a waste to energy plant to generate renewable electricity from their waste water emissions. (recycled paper starts out at about 98% water).

The system cost several $M and as the energy was classified as renewable and was exported to the grid the project had a 12 month payback. Not all energy projects have a 12 month payback but this one did.

On a part time basis Peter was also involved in the construction and management of an on shore Abalone Farm on the Bellarine Peninsula near St Leonards in Victoria. They had to provide a backup power generator in case the power went off, otherwise the abalone would not have survived if the water in their pools got too hot.

Peter likes most wines; particularly Cool Climate wines.

Sustainability Judge

Jeni Port

Jeni Port is a Melbourne-based wine journalist who was a cadet on The Sun News-Pictorial (now Herald-Sun) when she caught the wine bug. While working in the paper’s Women’s Section she started writing about the role of women – including some of the very few women winemakers at the time – and eventually started the paper’s first wine column. She then moved to The Age where she was a member of the wine writing team for 30 years.

She now works as a writer/critic for the Halliday Wine Companion and WinePilot and writes for a number of magazines.

Apart from writing books on wine, she has been an active wine judge working within the Australian wine show system as well as overseas for Mundus Vini (Germany) and Concours Mondial de Bruxelles.

She is a founding board member of Australian Women In Wine, a group devoted to fighting for better opportunities, including equal pay, for women employed in the Australian wine industry.

Awards/Positions:
* WCA Wine Communicator of the Year 2014
* Legend of the Melbourne Food & Wine Festival 2014
* Deputy Chair Australia’s Wine List of the Year Awards / China’s Wine List of the Year Awards
* Tasting Panel Member: Halliday Wine Companion/ WinePilot

Books:
* Choosing Australian Wines (Penguin);
* Crushed By Women: Women and Wine (Arcadia), * Australian/NZ contributor, Wines of the World (Dorling Kindersley),
* contributor to The Wine Lover’s Bucket List (Universe),
* contributor, Melbourne: The Making of a Eating & Drinking Capital (Hardie Grant),
* annual contributor, Halliday Wine Companion (Hardie Grant)